Newton Abbot, Kingsteignton, Teignmouth and Dawlish sit within about eight miles of each other. Locals move between them without thinking. Google does not.
Each town is a separate search market with its own results, and ranking well in one buys you very little in the next. Businesses discover this the hard way, usually after months of doing fine in their home town and wondering why the phone never rings from anywhere else.
- Kingsteignton and Newton Abbot practically touch. They are still distinct in search, and a Newton Abbot pin does not automatically win Kingsteignton.
- Teignmouth and Shaldon are two hundred metres apart across the water. By road it is roughly six miles round the estuary. Google measures the straight line, but your customers drive the long way, which changes who is genuinely worth targeting.
- Dawlish sits on its own. Far enough down the coast that Newton Abbot businesses rarely rank there, which is an opportunity if you are in Dawlish and a warning if you are not.
So the question is never just how do I rank locally. It is which of these towns actually pays, and are you set up to win those specifically.